Peer Assessment Question 1b Portfolio
Question/Theory: Genre
Student name: Nathan Erinle
MEG: Working at Grade:
List theorists & theories referenced:
1 Levi-Strauss
2Barthes
3Propp
4 Domaille
5
List terminology words: binary opposition
Etherior structure
All of the 5 Narrative codes
Antagonist
Protagonist
Equilibrium
Disequilibrium
Stock
Faust
Level
Description
Ref no
Grade
Agree?
Level 1:
Outlines or describes 1 theorist with little reference to own production, and is under 250 words (1 side handwritten A4)
U
Yes
Level 2 lower:
Introduces and describes 2-3 relevant theories using some correct terminology/theorists
E
Yes
Level 2 mid:
Provides some examples but inconsistently and/or lacks correct explanation of how it applies
E/D-
Yes
Level 2 higher:
Provides a maximum of 2 theories and introduces correctly in some depth and with some reference to own production
D
Yes
Level 3 lower:
The essay uses paragraphs and full sentences, there are minimal errors in grammar or spelling
C-
Yes
Level 3 lower:
Gives specific textual examples from own production of how 3-4 theories can be applied
C
Yes
Level 3 mid:
Explains why or how it is relevant or significant to own production rather than explaining the theory
C/B-
No
Level 3 higher:
Discusses how the theory is or is not applicable and gives reasons to justify, possibly referring to existing media or creative intentions
B
No
Level 3 higher:
Consistently analyses how the theoretical approach creates significance or meaning
B+
Yes
Level 4:
Evaluates the extent that 4 or more theories are applicable, with justification in relation to creative intentions
A
Level 4:
Confidently justifies argument with detailed textual examples from the production and conventions of existing media it is based on
A
Level 4:
There are no or minimal grammatical or spelling errors and terminology is used confidently, regularly and correctly
A
What are the 3 priority targets to secure the grade or move to a higher level
1. Application of theory and analysis
2. Use of examples
3. Use of terminology
Question/Theory:
Narrative
Student name:
MEG: Working at Grade:
List theorists & theories referenced:
1 Todorov 3 act structure
2 Levi Strauss Binary Opposition
3 Barthes Enigma Code
4 Propp Archetypes
5
List terminology words: equilibrium
Disequilibrium
Stock
Binary opposition
Connote
Systematic opposition
Phallic
Represent
Resolution
Enigmatic
Archetype
Cliché
Level
Description
Ref no
Grade
Agree?
Level 1:
Outlines or describes 1 theorist with little reference to own production, and is under 250 words (1 side handwritten A4)
U
Yes
Level 2 lower:
Introduces and describes 2-3 relevant theories using some correct terminology/theorists
E
Yes
Level 2 mid:
Provides some examples but inconsistently and/or lacks correct explanation of how it applies
E/D-
Yes
Level 2 higher:
Provides a maximum of 2 theories and introduces correctly in some depth and with some reference to own production
D
Yes
Level 3 lower:
The essay uses paragraphs and full sentences, there are minimal errors in grammar or spelling
C-
Yes
Level 3 lower:
Gives specific textual examples from own production of how 3-4 theories can be applied
C
Yes
Level 3 mid:
Explains why or how it is relevant or significant to own production rather than explaining the theory
C/B-
Yes
Level 3 higher:
Discusses how the theory is or is not applicable and gives reasons to justify, possibly referring to existing media or creative intentions
B
Yes
Level 3 higher:
Consistently analyses how the theoretical approach creates significance or meaning
B+
No
Level 4:
Evaluates the extent that 4 or more theories are applicable, with justification in relation to creative intentions
A no
Level 4:
Confidently justifies argument with detailed textual examples from the production and conventions of existing media it is based on
A yes
Level 4:
There are no or minimal grammatical or spelling errors and terminology is used confidently, regularly and correctly
A no
What are the 3 priority targets to secure the grade or move to a higher level
1. Application of theory and analysis
2. Use of examples
3. Use of terminology
Question/Theory:
Student name:
MEG: Working at Grade:
List theorists & theories referenced:
1 Sarah Dobbs Feminism
2 Carol Clover Final Girl Theory
3 Laura Mulvey Male Gaze
4
5
List terminology words:
Hegemony
Stock scenes
Camera cuts
Enigma code
Masculinised
Sexualised
Perspective
Voyeurism
Level
Description
Ref no
Grade
Agree?
Level 1:
Outlines or describes 1 theorist with little reference to own production, and is under 250 words (1 side handwritten A4)
U
Yes
Level 2 lower:
Introduces and describes 2-3 relevant theories using some correct terminology/theorists
E
Yes
Level 2 mid:
Provides some examples but inconsistently and/or lacks correct explanation of how it applies
E/D-
Yes
Level 2 higher:
Provides a maximum of 2 theories and introduces correctly in some depth and with some reference to own production
D
Yes
Level 3 lower:
The essay uses paragraphs and full sentences, there are minimal errors in grammar or spelling
C-
Yes
Level 3 lower:
Gives specific textual examples from own production of how 3-4 theories can be applied
C
Yes
Level 3 mid:
Explains why or how it is relevant or significant to own production rather than explaining the theory
C/B-
Yes
Level 3 higher:
Discusses how the theory is or is not applicable and gives reasons to justify, possibly referring to existing media or creative intentions
B
No
Level 3 higher:
Consistently analyses how the theoretical approach creates significance or meaning
B+
No
Level 4:
Evaluates the extent that 4 or more theories are applicable, with justification in relation to creative intentions
A no
Level 4:
Confidently justifies argument with detailed textual examples from the production and conventions of existing media it is based on
A no
Level 4:
There are no or minimal grammatical or spelling errors and terminology is used confidently, regularly and correctly
A yes
What are the 3 priority targets to secure the grade or move to a higher level
1. Application of theory and analysis
2. Use of examples
3. Use of terminology
Question/Theory:
Student name:
MEG: Working at Grade:
List theorists & theories referenced:
1 hypodermic model
2 reception theory Stuart Hall
3 Bulmer and Katz uses and gratification
4 copy cat theory
5
List terminology words: consumer
Audience
Passive and active
Mass audience
Institution
Hypodermic model
Reception
Coded and decoded
Personal social integrative
Tension free needs
Cognitive needs
Copycat
Level
Description
Ref no
Grade
Agree?
Level 1:
Outlines or describes 1 theorist with little reference to own production, and is under 250 words (1 side handwritten A4)
U
Yes
Level 2 lower:
Introduces and describes 2-3 relevant theories using some correct terminology/theorists
E
Yes
Level 2 mid:
Provides some examples but inconsistently and/or lacks correct explanation of how it applies
E/D-
Yes
Level 2 higher:
Provides a maximum of 2 theories and introduces correctly in some depth and with some reference to own production
D
Yes
Level 3 lower:
The essay uses paragraphs and full sentences, there are minimal errors in grammar or spelling
C-
Yes
Level 3 lower:
Gives specific textual examples from own production of how 3-4 theories can be applied
C
Yes
Level 3 mid:
Explains why or how it is relevant or significant to own production rather than explaining the theory
C/B-
Yes
Level 3 higher:
Discusses how the theory is or is not applicable and gives reasons to justify, possibly referring to existing media or creative intentions
B
No
Level 3 higher:
Consistently analyses how the theoretical approach creates significance or meaning
B+
No
Level 4:
Evaluates the extent that 4 or more theories are applicable, with justification in relation to creative intentions
A no
Level 4:
Confidently justifies argument with detailed textual examples from the production and conventions of existing media it is based on
A no
Level 4:
There are no or minimal grammatical or spelling errors and terminology is used confidently, regularly and correctly
A no
What are the 3 priority targets to secure the grade or move to a higher level
1. Application of theory and analysis
2. Use of examples
3. Use of terminology